THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE JUDGE OF GUARANTEES IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ADVERSE PROCEDURE SYSTEM: An Analysis of the Experience in Sergipe
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17564/2316-3143.2026v10n1p46-59Published
Downloads
Downloads
Issue
Section
License
Oferece acesso livre e imediato ao seu conteúdo, seguindo o princípio de que disponibilizar gratuitamente o conhecimento científico contribui para a democratização do saber. Assume-se que, ao submeter os originais os autores cedem os direitos de publicação para o Caderno de Graduação. O autor(a) reconhece esta como detentor(a) do direito autoral e ele autoriza seu livre uso pelos leitores, podendo ser, além de lido, baixado, copiado, distribuído e impresso, desde quando citada a fonte.Abstract
This article aims to describe, from a critical perspective, the implementation process of the "guarantees judge" (*juiz das garantias*) within the Judiciary of the State of Sergipe. To this end, the analysis covers everything from the legislative process to the current stage and the main challenges faced during the implementation of this legal mechanism by the Court of Justice of Sergipe. The methodology employed was based on bibliographic research—drawing upon documentary, legal, doctrinal, and jurisprudential sources to support a qualitative study—as well as empirical research involving on-site data collection at the judicial unit. The study reveals the success of the Sergipe Judiciary's experience in establishing the Guarantees Unit (*Núcleo de Garantias*), although it also highlights criticisms regarding the lack of an adaptation and testing period, as well as insufficient staffing increases in light of the anticipated rise in caseloads. It concludes that this role, far from hindering the efficiency of criminal justice, constitutes an essential instrument for ensuring judicial impartiality and promoting a truly adversarial criminal justice system. However, its success in Sergipe will ultimately depend on the Judiciary's institutional commitment to the continuous improvement of its Guarantees Unit; the Unit's role in overseeing criminal investigations and safeguarding individual rights throughout the state is fundamental to fostering criminal proceedings that are increasingly aligned with constitutional values.







