THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 103/2019: ANALYSIS OF THE IMPACTS ON THE METHODOLOGY FOR CALCULATING THE VALUE OF PERMANENT DISABILITY RETIREMENT BENEFITS

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17564/2316-3143.2026v10n1p9-20

Authors

  • Natália Viana Moura Tiradentes University
  • Amanda Greff Escobar Charlot Tiradentes University

Published

2026-11-11

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Issue

Section

Artigos

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the constitutional and social impacts of the changes introduced by Constitutional Amendment No. 103/2019 on the calculation of Permanent Disability Retirement, especially regarding the possible violation of the principles of human dignity, equality, non-reduction of benefits, and prohibition of social regression. To this end, a qualitative approach, deductive method, and exploratory character were adopted, using bibliographic and documentary research and jurisprudential analysis. The investigation demonstrates that, before the reform, the benefit corresponded to 100% of the contributory average, while, after EC No. 103/2019, the general rule of 60% of the average salaries, plus percentages conditioned on the contribution time, except in cases of work-related accidents, began to apply. The results show that the new methodology significantly reduced the value of social security protection, affecting more intensely permanently disabled insured individuals who depend entirely on the benefit for their subsistence. The jurisprudence of the first-instance courts has recognized the unconstitutionality of the rule, while the Supreme Federal Court, in the judgment of Theme 1300, through the rapporteur's vote, understood the norm to be constitutional, based on the principles of judicial self-restraint and actuarial balance, even though there was significant divergence. It is concluded that the change promoted by Constitutional Amendment No. 103/2019 represents a social setback by reducing protection for the most vulnerable insured individuals, generating interpretative tension between the need for the system's sustainability and the effectiveness of fundamental rights, which reinforces the need for a critical reassessment of the established model.

How to Cite

Viana Moura, N., & Greff Escobar Charlot, A. (2026). THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 103/2019: ANALYSIS OF THE IMPACTS ON THE METHODOLOGY FOR CALCULATING THE VALUE OF PERMANENT DISABILITY RETIREMENT BENEFITS. Caderno De Graduação - Ciências Humanas E Sociais - UNIT - SERGIPE, 10(1), 9–20. https://doi.org/10.17564/2316-3143.2026v10n1p9-20